Monday, March 4, 2019

People's Draft (a crowd-sourced constitution) executive summary

Executive Summary

The People’s Draft[i] is a crowd-sourced constitution framed in 2018 at the initiative of Tanggulang Demokrasya (Tan Dem), Inc.[ii] and PUBLiCUS Asia, Inc.[iii] These organizations are comprised of citizens who firmly believe that constitutional reform is needed to finally change the nation’s course of history, towards a strong republic and respected member of the international community.

The People’s Draft is the simplest draft. It is a 10-page constitution (with a 2-page ordinance). About 70% of the language is adopted from previous constitutions (i.e. 1987, 1973, 1935). It uses common concepts (like President, Congress, Supreme Court) that are understood by the people.

It is the broadest draft covering (1) “Foreign investment liberalization” (for massive job creation and consumer price reduction, subject to limits by Congress); (2) “Collective rule” by a national parliament and the local councils (for joint responsibility, collective wisdom, harmonized legislation and execution, and platform-based party politics instead of personality-based politics); and (3) “Regional decentralization” via the “bottom-up” approach instead of the “top-down” approach (to uphold the people’s right to self-determination). 

The People’s Draft presents the only cost-saving option:
·       Con-Com draft: PhP40,876,211,465.00 est. annual cost
·       PDP-Laban draft: PhP30,327,617,981.00 est. annual cost
·       People’s Draft: PhP13,457,281,108.00 est. annual savings

It restructures the “political branch” by merging the “executive” with the “legislature” (to establish a strong government). Nonetheless, it retains the separation of the judiciary, being the “non-political branch” (for checks and balances).

It phases “regional decentralization” based on “subsidiarity” and “accession,” establishing a “unitary state” but provides regions an option for transition to a “federal state.” It adopts asymmetric decentralization, enabling the people to choose either a regional authority (like SBMA), autonomous region (like BARMM) or substate (like Sabah). NO region is forced to, or prevented from, creating an autonomous region or substate.

The People’s Draft boosts political efficiency with:
(1)  NO duplication of legislation; unicameral assembly avoids bicameral delay and deadlock; faster than bicameral process requiring 3 approvals, i.e. house, senate, bicameral committee;
(2)  NO overlapping jurisdiction of LGUs; City & Municipality as main LGU; Mayor as primary local official;
(3)  NO bloating of bureaucracy; Mayors and district Representatives as ex-officio members of higher bodies (i.e. provincial board, regional assembly); and
(4)  NO excessive politics; local councils elect local chiefs (i.e. Governor, Mayor, Punong Barangay); Mayors appoint barangay kagawad nominated by community associations.

The People’s Draft anchors political stability with:
(1)  NO term extension for any elective official, including the President, Vice-President, Senators, Representatives, all local elective officials;
(2)  NO term reduction for any elective official; Senators elected in May 2019 serve as ex-officio members of the new Congress until June 2025;
(3)  NO reorganization of Supreme Court; Justices continue old terms under the new Constitution;
(4)  NO service disruption for all officers and employees of the national government and the LGUs; and
(5)  Provides a 5-year term for Representatives & Councilors.

The People’s Draft promotes political democracy that:                                  
(1)  Secures the people’s right to elect the President or Mayor via party voting; the ballots disclose both the candidate and the nominee for chief executive (aka electoral college);
(2)  Enables political parties to win elective posts with less votes (i.e. less campaign expenses) via elections in multiple small districts instead of one large district (i.e. Congress, local council);
(3)  Retains 3-term limit for Representatives and Councilors;
(4)  Bars 2 or more family members from running in elections in the same national or local constituency;
(5)  Provides for dissolution of Congress and fresh elections if the need arises for a popular vote of confidence on fundamental issues; and
(6)  Provides for manual safeguards to automated elections.

The People’s Draft strengthens political accountability that:
(1)    Provides for the immediate removal of the chief executive (i.e. President, Governor, Mayor, Punong Barangay) via a “vote of no confidence” (i.e. Congress, local council);
(2)    Provides for the mid-term recall of congressional Representatives; and
(3)    Limits impeachment to Supreme Court Justices only (excluding CSC, Comelec, COA & Ombudsman).

The People’s Draft champions genuine social reforms that: (1) Ensures the genuine representation of sectors and peoples in Congress via sectoral voting (i.e. workers’ associations under DOLE not party-list groups under Comelec); (2) Reserves seats in Congress for labor, farmers, fishermen, youth, Southern Sultanates and Lumads; and (3) Mandates legal recognition of the Southern Sultanates, but Sovereignty and ALL political powers are retained by the People and the Government.

The People’s Draft promotes the national identity based on the people’s Southeast Asian culture. It institutes Lakan as the head of state; establishes a Lupong Pambansa as the council of state (i.e. council of elders); mandates the recognition of the Southern Sultanates; affirms the Lumad peoples and their ancestral lands; and provides inclusive linguistic bases for the national language.[iv]

The People’s Draft defends the national sovereignty. It reinstates the broad legal bases (i.e. historic right, legal title) of the national territory (i.e. legal jurisdiction over Kalayaan Islands; historical claims to Sabah). By recognizing the Sulu Sultanate, it strengthens the kingdom’s proprietary claims to Sabah.

The People’s Draft ensures a stable economy with: (1) NO new taxes by substates on imports, exports, income, value added, unless allowed by Congress; (2) NO new laws by substates on currency, banking, insurance, insolvency, commerce, intellectual property, professions, immigration & naturalization, unless allowed by Congress; and (3) NO additional budget for basic Regional Authorities, because the existing regional offices of select line departments[v] will ONLY be integrated and consolidated into the major regions.[vi]

The People’s Draft protects the national security. There will be NO “Balkanization” (or breakup of the State) because the new Constitution prohibits secession and the establishment of military & police forces by any substate. ONLY “internal security forces” (to protect persons & properties) will be allowed.


[i] Facebook: #PeoplesDraft. Twitter: @PeoplesDraft.
[ii] TanDem is an NGO. In pursuit of “system change” and/or “electoral reforms,” TanDem has collaborated with various organizations, including the Center for Preservation of Historical Rights of the Sulu Archipelago, Citizen National Guard (CNG), Federation of Free Workers (FFW), Global Filipino Nation (GFN), Lumad Mindanao Peoples Federation (LMPF), Network Revolution (RevGov) and Philippine Constitution Association (Philconsa).
[iii] Publicus is a lobby firm.
[iv] National language based on Tagalog, and enriched by Cebuano, Ilocano, Hiligaynon, Waray-Waray, Bikol, Kapangpangan, Pangasinan, Maranao, Tausug, Maguindanao and Kinaray-a, among others.
[v] All departments and attached agencies, except DND, DILG, DFA, DOJ, DOF, DBM, NEDA and BSP.
[vi] NCR, Cordillera, Luzon, Visayas, Mindanao & Bangsamoro regions.

No comments:

Post a Comment